Insights

Lucy Letby And The Whistleblowing Debate

19.10.2023

4 minute read

Authored by

Emma McLoughlin

Senior Associate Solicitor

Message

Share

LinkedIn icon

Many news outlets have been following the case of Lucy Letby with some now focusing on calls for an investigation into whether there was a failure to heed warnings given by her colleagues.

In this context, the word ‘whistleblower’ is thrown around, but what does this actually mean for individuals in an employment context?

The law protects employees from being dismissed and prevents employees or workers from being subjected to a detriment on the grounds that they have appropriately made a protected disclosure. Concerns can be raised at any time about an incident that happened in the past, is happening now or which you believe will happen soon.

Acas sets out some examples of what could amount to a protected disclosure, for example:

  • a criminal offence – e.g, if an employer has been trying to bribe people
  • the breach of a legal obligation by an organisation – e.g, if an employer has neglected their duty of care towards children in a care home
  • a miscarriage of justice – e.g, if a member of staff has been fired for something that turned out to be a computer error
  • someone’s health and safety being in danger – e.g, if an employer has forced staff to serve food they know has been contaminated
  • damage to the environment – e.g, if an employer has been regularly polluting local rivers

There is also a prescribed list of people or bodies to whom you can make such disclosures, again listed on the Acas website.

Sometimes confusion arises between a genuine whistleblowing disclosure and a grievance. Equally, some aggrieved employees will seek to rely on whistleblower protection when pursuing a claim knowing that there is no financial cap on compensation in whistleblowing claims and no requirement for a minimum period of service.

It is important to remember that the disclosure must be in the public interest, which means it should usually affect others such as workers, customers or the general public. Therefore, if you have an issue or grievance that is just personal to you, it is unlikely to satisfy the conditions to afford you protection and you should consider other avenues for addressing your concerns.

Other than in certain sectors, there is no positive legal obligation on an employer to have a whistleblowing policy. Even if your employer does not have such a policy though or has a “paper policy” which is not effectively enforced, you will still benefit from whistleblower protection.

Many employers now recognise the importance and benefits of effective whistleblowing and will have policies that seek to encourage effective internal whistleblowing and protect whistleblowers. If your employer does have such a policy, it is useful to review it before making a report.

It remains to be seen whether any of the recommendations out of the anticipated Judge led enquiry into the Lucy Letby case will involve any change to the law on “protected disclosures”.

In the meantime, if you need assistance through navigating and understanding the law around whistleblowing or feel you have been treated unfairly or suffered a detriment as a result of making such a report, do contact your usual legal adviser or a member of the employment team.

How can Morr & Co help?

If you have any questions or would like any further information on the content of this article, please do not hesitate to contact our Employment team on 01737 854500 or email info@morrlaw.com and a member of our expert team will get back to you.

Disclaimer
Although correct at the time of publication, the contents of this newsletter/blog are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute, legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article. Please contact us for the latest legal position.

Stay informed

Receive regular insights and updates from our legal experts.

Get in touch

Receive regular insights and updates from our legal experts

Please choose from the below options so that we can direct your enquiry to the right team member

Sorry, we do not provide criminal law advice.

You may wish to contact your local Citizens Advice Bureau or your local Law Centre, who will be able to help you find support.

Sorry, we do not provide advice on consumer disputes.

You may wish to contact your local Citizens Advice Bureau or your local Law Centre, who will be able to help you find support.

Sorry, we do not provide advice on benefits related disputes.

You may wish to contact your local Citizens Advice Bureau or your local Law Centre, who will be able to help you find support.


Please note that we are currently only providing this service to our existing clients.

You should bear in mind that if your dispute is valued at less than £10,000 you will not be able to recover your legal fees from your opponent.

You may wish to consider consulting the Citizens Advice Bureau or your local Law Centre as an alternative.

In order to enable us to give you an accurate estimate of our likely costs to advise you, we will need to review the key documents. As a guide, our costs for reviewing the key documents and giving you initial advice are likely to be in the region of £1,750+VAT.

Before we can confirm whether we are able to act for you, we need to carry out a conflict check to make sure that we have not previously acted for your opponent.

Assuming our conflict check is clear, we will contact you to arrange a time for you to speak to one of our solicitors. Please can you confirm that you still wish to proceed with this enquiry. *

Our fees for debt recovery work typically start at £1,750 + VAT, so it is unlikely that we would be able to help you on this occasion. You may wish to contact the Citizens Advice Bureau or your local law centre, who may be able to help resolve your issue.

We are sorry that we are not able to help you on this occasion.

You may wish to contact the Citizens Advice Bureau or your local law centre, who may be able to help resolve your issue.

If your claim relates to an incident that took place more than 4 years ago, you may not be able to bring a claim unless you were under 18 years old at the time.

We are sorry, but it is unlikely that we are able to help you with your claim on this occasion.

You may wish to contact the Citizens Advice Bureau or your local law centre, who will be able to help you find support.