Many Spanish properties occupy a special place in family life. A villa, apartment or holiday home may represent years of memories, family holidays and parental generosity. For that reason, many clients assume that leaving the property equally to their children is the fairest and simplest approach. Sometimes it is. But what appears fair from a succession perspective does not always produce a workable arrangement once the property has been inherited. Children who enjoyed the property equally during their parents’ lifetime may have very different views about it once they inherit it. One may love it and want to keep it. One may see it as an investment. One may want it sold as quickly as possible. Another may live too far away, have no interest in Spain, or resent being asked to pay maintenance costs for a property they rarely use. The difficulty is not usually deciding who should inherit. The difficulty is recognising that equal treatment does not always require equal ownership of the same asset. A child who regularly uses and maintains the Spanish property may value it very differently from a sibling who lives overseas and has little connection with it. In those circumstances, leaving the property to one beneficiary and, where possible, balancing the position from other assets may produce a more practical outcome than dividing ownership equally. Why shared ownership of inherited Spanish property can be difficult Where several beneficiaries inherit Spanish property together, they do not simply inherit an asset. They inherit a set of responsibilities and decisions. Who can use the property, and when? Who pays the comunidad fees, local taxes, insurance and repairs? Should the property be let? If so, who manages it? What happens if one beneficiary wants to sell and another does not? Who deals with Spanish lawyers, notaries, banks and tax authorities? These issues can be manageable where the beneficiaries have a shared view of what should happen to the property. They become much harder where family relationships are already strained, or where the property means different things to different people. Case study Three siblings, three different plans: Sibling strife in Sitges Peter and Marian owned a small apartment near Sitges, which they had bought many years earlier. Their three adult children had grown up spending holidays there. Peter and Marian assumed the children would want to keep the apartment in the family, so their Wills left their estate equally between them. On paper, this seemed fair. After Peter and Marian had both died, the Spanish apartment passed equally to the three siblings: Anna, Ben and Claire. Anna loved the property. She had young children and wanted to keep it for family holidays. Ben saw an opportunity to generate income and wanted to place it on short-term holiday letting platforms. Claire had emigrated to New Zealand, rarely returned to Europe and wanted her share converted into cash. None of those positions was unreasonable. What had never been addressed was whether equal ownership of the apartment would still make sense once the children became owners rather than holidaymakers. What happened when the siblings inherited the apartment At first, the siblings tried to manage matters informally. Anna used the apartment during school holidays. Ben objected that this blocked peak letting weeks. Claire objected to paying one-third of the expenses for a property she did not use and did not want to keep. Maintenance issues then arose. The air conditioning needed replacing. Community fees increased. Local tax demands had to be dealt with. A Spanish bank account needed attention. Insurance had to be renewed. The keys were held by a neighbour who had informally helped Peter and Marian for years, but who did not want continuing responsibility. What had seemed like an equal and generous inheritance became a point of recurring conflict. Why the Spanish property was eventually sold The property was eventually sold, but only after delay, disagreement and additional professional fees. The problem was not that Peter and Marian had treated the children unequally. The problem was that they had focused on dividing the value of the estate equally, rather than considering whether equal ownership of the apartment remained the most sensible solution for the next generation. A different outcome may have been available. The beneficiary most likely to use and maintain the property could have inherited it outright, with the others receiving equivalent value from elsewhere in the estate. Even where a property has already been inherited jointly, alternative solutions may be available. Depending on the circumstances, one beneficiary may be able to retain the property while the others receive value for their respective interests, avoiding the need for an immediate sale. How succession planning can reduce family disputes The problem was not that Peter and Marian wanted to treat their children equally. The problem was assuming that equal ownership of the apartment was necessarily the best way of achieving that aim. Where a Spanish property forms part of an estate, the question is often not simply who should inherit it? It is also who will use it, who will maintain it, and who will be responsible for it? Those questions are usually easier to answer during lifetime than after death. Planning who should inherit a Spanish holiday home If one beneficiary is most likely to use and maintain the property, it may be more practical for that person to inherit it, with the other beneficiaries receiving equivalent value from elsewhere in the estate. The right approach will depend on the family, the available assets and how the English and Spanish arrangements work together. How Morr & Co can help with Spanish property inheritance If you own a property or other assets in Spain, coordinated planning can help you decide how they should pass and reduce the risk of avoidable disagreement between beneficiaries. Find out more about our Will writing for Spanish estates and our wider Anglo-Spanish property and inheritance service or contact our Private Client team by emailing info@morrlaw.com or calling us on 0333 038 9100. Explanatory note For ease of reading, references in this article to “English” Wills, law, trusts, probate, estate administration and related legal concepts generally mean those governed by the law of England and Wales. Disclaimer Although correct at the time of publication, the contents of this newsletter/blog are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute, legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article. Please contact us for the latest legal position. Authored by Dennis Phillips Partner Message Tags Insights On this page Related Stories What happens if a Will made in England and Wales excludes Spanish property? Can a Will made in England and Wales cover Spanish property? Can a Spanish Will accidentally revoke your Will made in England and Wales? View more Contact our team today get in touch